But the 19,713‑square‑foot main house at Hidden Hollow Ranch is more than a luxury listing – it’s a private retreat built on 415 acres of woodland, a nine‑acre stocked lake, and a licensed hunting preserve. Six bedrooms, eight full bathrooms, a koi stream, a two‑story waterfall, and an 8,700‑gallon aquarium give the property an almost mythical feel that few homes can match.
Stewart first listed the ranch for $30 million in 2022, citing it as his dream home. After withdrawing it from the market in 2023, the property resurfaced in 2024 at $22.5 million, shaving $7.5 million off the original asking price. Today, Realtor.com shows the listing at $18.9 million, a further $3.6 million reduction that signals a shift in market strategy.
Realtor.com reports that the property now appears on the market for the first time since 2022, and a broker noted that high‑net‑worth buyers are showing interest. The ranch’s unique amenities – a 1,500‑gallon koi stream, a 3,500‑sq‑ft guest house, and a licensed hunting preserve – make it a rare niche asset, but the steep price may narrow the buyer pool.
The next step will be to see whether offers materialize in the coming weeks. If the ranch sells at or near its current price, it could set a new benchmark for high‑end properties in Indiana and signal a broader trend toward price adjustments in the luxury real‑estate market.