The building at 72 The Crescent, Tyabb, Victoria, hit the market this week with a guide price between $865,000 and $950,000. It was originally built as a Methodist church in 1923. Over the decades, it served as a Sunday school, a dance school, and now a three-bedroom home. The structure has survived multiple transformations, each layer adding to its character.
Inside, the former church hall now serves as the main living and dining area. It features soaring cathedral ceilings, exposed structural timbers, original windows, and coloured glass. The polished floorboards and modern kitchen create a contrast between old and new. The kitchen includes a substantial island, a dishwasher, and a freestanding cooker, all set against the backdrop of the historic walls.
The bedrooms, located in a wing that was rebuilt into a modern layout, retain some original details like doors and skirtings. The main bedroom comes with a walk-in wardrobe, a private en suite, and access to a secluded patio. The other two bedrooms also have walk-in wardrobes and share a family bathroom. A separate powder room is also available. One of the smaller original rooms, once the priest’s office, now serves as the laundry.
Outside, French doors open onto a broad entertaining deck, leading to a secure lawn and an established garden. The property includes a driveway, a double carport, and an extra hardstand for larger vehicles. A separate outbuilding and former side rooms provide storage for bikes, garden tools, and everyday items. The listing describes the sale as a "rare opportunity to become the next custodian of an extraordinary local landmark."