
KASARAGOD — A political storm broke over the Kerala administration on Thursday after dignitaries sat down mid-song during an official rendition of Vande Mataram.
Bharatiya Janata Party leaders announced immediate legal and administrative petitions targeting Kasaragod District Collector Sreedhanya Suresh. The party confirmed it will appeal directly to Union Home Minister Amit Shah, Kerala Governor Raj Bhavan, and the state administration to initiate punitive proceedings against the IAS officer.
The altercation erupted inside the Muliyar Family Health Centre during an inauguration ceremony for a newly constructed laboratory. Video footage captured Kerala Minister K Muraleedharan, Member of Parliament Rajmohan Unnithan, MLA K Mahin, and District Collector Suresh taking their seats immediately after the vocalists completed the first two stanzas. Other stanzas continued from the microphones. Sitting on the dais, Muraleedharan turned to converse with accompanying delegates while the music played. Yet two figures remained erect. MLA K Neelakandan and District Congress Committee president P K Faisal stood at attention through the final note.
The optics ignited instant outrage.
Political confrontation followed within hours. The BJP zeroed in on Suresh, an Indian Administrative Service officer, demanding immediate accountability under the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act. The party alleged the bureaucrat breached statutory protocol by breaking posture before the national song ended.
The collector has to follow the protocols of the Union. It is appalling that she didn't stand up.
Ashwini M.L., BJP Kasaragod District President
BJP functionaries accused Suresh of political bias, claiming links between the administrator and the Congress party's student wing, the Kerala Students Union. The party argued elected representatives might hide behind legislative politics, but civil servants answer directly to Union personnel conduct rules.
| Official on Dais | Official Position | Action Taken During Stanza 3 | Protocol Status Cited |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sreedhanya Suresh | Kasaragod District Collector (IAS) | Took seat after stanza two | Union Civil Service Rules / National Honour Act |
| K Muraleedharan | Kerala State Minister | Took seat and engaged in conversation | Kerala State Protocol (Two-stanza rule) |
| Rajmohan Unnithan | Member of Parliament | Took seat after stanza two | Event invocation schedule dispute |
Muraleedharan rejected the accusations outright. He insisted the event schedule distributed to organizers never scheduled the national song in its entirety.
Panchayat-level functions, Muraleedharan maintained, observe strict Kerala government guidelines that list only an 'Ishwara Prarthana'—an invocation—at the start of civic events. Under those state guidelines, official functions include only the first two stanzas of Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay's composition. Muraleedharan questioned how the full-length rendition entered the Muliyar program without advance coordination.
"I am a son of a freedom fighter," Muraleedharan said. "I don't need to prove my patriotism to anyone."
Yet the dispute exposes an ongoing legal and operational friction between state departments and central protocols over civic symbolism. While Kerala state administrative conventions limit public choir performances of the song to two stanzas to conserve event time, central statutory conventions demand full physical observance whenever the song sounds in administrative auditoriums.
BJP Kasaragod leaders confirmed formal complaint dossiers will reach the Union Ministry of Home Affairs and Raj Bhavan by the end of the week, with district-wide protest rallies scheduled if the Kerala Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department refuses an inquiry.
| K Mahin |
| Member of the Legislative Assembly |
| Took seat after stanza two |
| Event invocation schedule dispute |
| K Neelakandan | Member of the Legislative Assembly | Remained standing until conclusion | Full national song observance |
| P K Faisal | DCC President | Remained standing until conclusion | Full national song observance |